„What Giles Martin has done will inevitably prompt controversy, as it‘s disrupting decades of accrued historical resonance. But if the 1987 CD of the „White Album“ parked us in the corridor, and the 2009 stereo remaster let us into the control room with the volumes cranked, Martin‘s remix feels like the closest anyone can get to sharing the headspace of the people who made the music. The detail is staggering.“
(Uncut, December)
„Giles Martin‘s new stereo mix succeeds, principally through lightness of touch. As with his take on „Pepper“, this is a rather subtle revision rather than a bold remake. Come to it unawares and you might not notice any difference. But listen closely on headphones and the magic of the new mix becomes clear.“
(Mojo, December)